The Freshwater Trail

The Indian government calls 68% of the Thar a "wasteland," and plans to "better utilize" it. Actions born of this new lexicon threaten to destroy livelihoods and an ecosystem at a time when monsoons are unpredictable

Arati Kumar-Rao
Photographer & Journalist

14 thoughts on “Blind Men And The Desert”

  1. Very evocative of the follies that have occurred time and time again all across this land, what from a local’s perspective can be read as unsolicited change. Reading this piece in entirety methinks – just out of frustration and remorse, that along with your excellent photo-documentation and writing, would a movie with this story unfolding perhaps also have added impact to a larger audience?

    • Arati Kumar-Rao
      July 6, 2015

      Thank you for writing in, Manish. Means a lot.
      I smiled at reading your suggestion of a film. It is something on my mind, something for the near future.

  2. Jaya Ghosh
    July 7, 2015

    Excellent article.

  3. Excellent piece. Perhaps someone could investigate the private parties who profited from these massive projects. But that maybe politically explosive.

  4. Sachin killawala
    July 7, 2015

    What a brilliant analysis. Thank you for taking the time to research this topic. The time is not too far where stuff like this is mainstream.. Hopefully not too late..

    • Arati Kumar-Rao
      July 14, 2015

      Thanks, Sachin, there are people working tirelessly to increase awareness of these ecosystems. So yes, hopefully, not too late.

  5. Prakash K Ray
    July 7, 2015

    Emphatic. Splendid. Bests to Arati and Peepli Team.

  6. Gaurav Garg
    July 13, 2015

    Fantastic read Arati. So evocative and well written.

  7. Chander Kolhi
    October 8, 2015

    Great effort. Such a wonderful article; picture have given an additional glory to it. There is a need to make the same story for Tharparkar, Sindh in Pakistan. Lifestyle of Thari people and their culture also needs attention.

  8. Its a bit late but i hope you read and reply to it.
    I have come across many articles on a lot of issues about problems associated with projects.
    Yet, rarely I see and hear people talk about solutions instead of just complaining. I don’t mean to undermine the issues arising but its better if we come up with solutions while doing so if we are serious about positive change.
    Good luck 🙂

  9. Amita Baviskar
    September 9, 2017

    A terrific essay, Aarti! You’ve captured the plunder and stupidity of development, as well as the crying need to build on grounded knowledge. I remembered Anupam Mishra and how he used local words to show communities’ ties to landscapes. Looking forward to more long essays from you!

  10. That’s what I have been advocating all this time bring experts,research scientist,involve public and then come up with a pilot project .These govt. Officers with title like IAS RCS will never be successful.If it becomes viable then go for it. What a detailed story and the descriptions is like novels of Tagore.I was planning to buy land in Jaisalmer but not anymore. Great job.

https://filipinosnacks.com/ https://retailr-d.virtualcity.co.ke/ https://staging.desconto.com.br/ https://stage-app.vitrinabox.com/ https://development.wisconsinstamping.com/ https://umbraco.fjordtours.com/ https://ellitest-nj.hms.com/ https://portal.epiclife.com/ https://staging-auth.sensoriafitness.com/ https://machinelearningtokyo.com/ https://identity-uber-qa.myblueship.com/ https://grub.asadosteakhouse.co.uk/ https://scascannerportal.cashconverters.com/ https://he.eudoradigital.com.br/ https://bluegreen.erastuspt.com/ https://dev.chsc-child.org https://www.esbmpf.ie/ https://timetabler-internal-dev.optime.cloud/ https://fn-ms-vianca-polyglot-bridge-v1-dev-wh.onelinkbpo.com/ https://payments.3dtraining.com https://customer.itsperfectonline.com/ https://pulstrac.pulsit.co.za/ https://www.yrityskehittamo.fi/ https://identity.nowpow.com/ https://hc-notificationservice-stage2.saddleback.com/ https://kre-d-app-containerpipelinetest.kredinor.no/ https://portal.huwelijksleveranciers.be/ https://importer.test.railcl.com/ https://staging.vienhealth.com/ https://www.blip.com.au/ https://exam-internal-dev.optime.cloud/ https://www.stonefinch.com/ https://www.swl.co.uk/ https://www.shimonakee.com/ https://campaigns.surveys.app.accustore.com/ https://presidenciales16.ceepur.org/ https://ventura.nortisinc.com.br/ https://housingdev.rubixx.co.uk/ https://toto228.it.com/ https://toto228.art/ https://www.mmm-fudge.com/shop/ https://dev.marketplace-api.infogreffe.latelier.co/ https://agendamento.delguercio.com.br/ https://pooch.blackcaps.co.nz/ https://novoportal.tecpay.com.br/ https://toto228.us.com/ https://toto228.uk.com/ https://auth.testhim.com/ https://wsr.optimusinfo.com/ https://test.weedscimeetingabstracts.com/ https://panglima4d.it.com/ https://toto228.com/register https://toto228.com/ https://2wivesbrickovenpizza.com/contact-us/ https://dtoperationsportal.otiselevator.com/ https://test-basecamp.tpsapps.org/ https://test.besavvi.co.uk/ https://audit.optime.cloud/ https://c113.foulefactory.com/ https://auth.quallogi.com/ https://www.paryushanmeals.org/ https://ch.moonideas.com/ https://wg.calderaycalderas.es/ https://hospitala.stage-next.nuvara.com/ https://meghalayaflc2023.vmukti.com/ https://www.stg.rizepoint.com/ https://piensa.upiicsa.tests.mx/ https://stella.dimonsystems.com/ https://game.thetechnocracy.com/ https://toto228-bd.com/ https://pmwr.evalidate.com/ https://app.testfit.com/ https://api-pms-oct.maersk.com/ https://i-cstopxref.meijer.com/ https://i-wiceligibility.meijer.com/ https://test.novunapersonalfinance.co.uk/ https://safeshore.uslh.org/ https://blogs.grupodharma.org/ https://pagos.finpact.org/